A 1958 Washington quarter graded MS68 by NGC sold for $4,560 at Heritage Auctions — yet most worn examples are worth just the silver in their metal. The secret is knowing which variety you have and what condition it's in. The ultra-rare Type B Reverse FS-901 reached $4,800 at auction. Use the free tools below to find exactly where your coin falls.
★★★★★ 4.8 / 5 based on 1,347 user ratings
Check My 1958 Quarter Value →Select your mint mark, condition, and any errors to get an instant estimate.
This calculator works best when you already know your coin's mint mark, condition, and errors — if you're still figuring those details out, try the 1958 Quarter Coin Value Checker online tool, a free third-party photo-based identifier that can help you identify key features before using the calculator above.
Describe what you see in plain language and our analyzer will highlight key value factors.
Skipped the calculator? Enter your mint mark and condition in seconds to get your coin's value range.
Use the Calculator →The 1958 Type B Reverse is the most valuable variety from this date — a PCGS MS67+ sold for $4,800 at Heritage Auctions in 2019. Use this checker to see if your coin might have it.
Check all 4 boxes if you see them on your coin:
The table below summarizes current market values across all major 1958 quarter varieties and conditions. For a complete step-by-step 1958 quarter identification breakdown with photos and grading tips, see this illustrated 1958 quarter identification walkthrough and reference guide. Values reflect the silver melt floor plus grade premiums based on recent PCGS/NGC auction data.
| Variety | Worn (G–F) | Circulated (VF–EF) | Uncirculated (MS-60–65) | Gem (MS-66–68+) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1958-P (No Mint Mark) | ~$13–$19 | ~$17–$20 | ~$20–$34 | $40–$4,560+ |
| 1958-D (Denver) | ~$13–$19 | ~$17–$20 | ~$20–$35 | $40–$19,555+ |
| 1958-P Type B Reverse FS-901 SIGNATURE | ~$16–$19 | ~$18–$35 | ~$35–$100 | $100–$4,800+ |
| 1958 Proof (Standard) | N/A | N/A | ~$22–$40 | $40–$200 |
| 1958 Proof Cameo (CAM) | N/A | N/A | ~$50–$120 | $100–$500 |
| 1958 Proof Deep Cameo (DCAM) RAREST | N/A | N/A | ~$150–$400 | $500–$8,519+ |
🔍 CoinKnow lets you snap a photo of your 1958 quarter and instantly cross-reference it against certified population data for a fast on-the-go value estimate — a coin identifier and value app.
Not all 1958 quarters are created equal. The five varieties below range from a readily identifiable die variety worth a consistent premium at MS-67+ to dramatic mint accidents that turn a silver quarter into a four-figure collectible. Each card explains exactly what to look for, why collectors pay a premium, and what the current market supports.
The 1958 Type B Reverse is the signature variety of the date and the one every serious collector of Washington quarters knows to hunt. It was produced when the Philadelphia Mint struck business-strike coins using retired proof reverse dies, creating coins with subtly enhanced design detail and, in many cases, proof-like or semi-proof-like mirror surfaces.
Visual identification requires a 10× loupe. On the Type B, the letters E and S in STATES are clearly separated by visible white space — on the standard Type A reverse, they crowd together. E PLURIBUS UNUM appears in noticeably higher relief, with each letter standing proudly off the surface rather than sitting flat. The die surfaces themselves frequently show the polished quality of proof dies.
PCGS catalogs this variety as FS-901 (PCGS #146067) and tracks it separately from the regular 1958-P issue. The market premium is substantial: a PCGS MS67+ example sold for $4,800 at Heritage Auctions in March 2019. An NGC MS64 example sold for $35 in May 2026, confirming that even mid-grade Type B coins trade above their plain counterparts. Collectors actively cherry-pick this variety from raw and already-slabbed coins.
Wrong planchet errors occur when a blank intended for a completely different denomination accidentally ends up in the press feeding a quarter die. During high-volume production in 1958, planchets for pennies, nickels, and dimes could occasionally mix into the feed system alongside the correct quarter blanks. The result is a coin struck with quarter imagery onto a blank of the wrong metal, size, or weight.
A documented example is a 1958-D quarter struck on a Lincoln cent planchet. Because the cent planchet is bronze — 95% copper — the resulting coin displays rich rose and orange tones entirely unlike the silver-gray of a normal quarter. The coin is also noticeably smaller and lighter, as cent planchets (3.11 grams) weigh far less than the standard quarter planchet (6.30 grams). The design will be partially truncated since a cent blank can't fully contain the quarter design.
Wrong planchet errors are among the most visually dramatic mint mistakes and command serious collector interest. The combination of a silver-era date with a clearly visible copper planchet creates an immediately compelling exhibit coin. Market prices for documented 1958 wrong planchet errors range from $500 to $1,500 or more depending on the host planchet denomination, the visual drama of the piece, and whether it is certified by PCGS or NGC.
A curved clip error happens during the blanking stage, before the coin is ever struck. When the punch press cuts round blanks from a long metal strip, it must avoid re-punching areas already cut. If the strip is not fed forward properly, the punch overlaps a previously cut hole — shearing an arc-shaped section from the new blank. The resulting planchet has a concave curved bite taken out of its edge, matching the circumference of the previously punched hole.
On a 1958 quarter curved clip, the missing section is clearly visible as a smooth, curved indentation in the coin's edge. Because the planchet weighed less than normal, the completed coin may show the Blakesley Effect — a weakness directly opposite the clip where metal was insufficient to fill the die cavity. This diagnostic feature, named after the engineer who first described it, is a reliable way to distinguish genuine clips from post-mint damage.
Curved clips are among the most commonly encountered major mint errors on 20th-century silver coins, partly because blanking operations were high-speed and imperfect. A 1958 quarter curved clip in clearly identifiable condition with visible Blakesley Effect and certification from PCGS or NGC typically achieves $75–$400 at auction. Larger clips (missing more than 15% of the planchet) command the highest premiums.
Die chip errors occur when a small fragment breaks away from the working die face during production. That missing chip creates a void in the die — and with every subsequent strike, that void fills with coin metal, leaving a small raised blob or dome on the coin's surface. The blobs appear in the same location on every coin struck from that die until the die was replaced or the chip grew into a full cud break.
Struck-through errors are a different beast: they occur when a foreign object — a piece of wire, a cloth fiber, a grease plug, or a metal fragment — lands between the die and the planchet at the moment of striking. The foreign material prevents metal from flowing into that section of the die, creating a corresponding incuse (sunken) area or smeared impression on the coin's surface. The impression can resemble a smear, a channel, or a faint outline of the obstructing material.
Die chip errors on 1958 quarters are most impactful when the chip occurs within a letter or numeral, distorting the design character. The "Double Bar 5" variety is one specific die-chip manifestation for this date, where the numeral 5 in the date shows an extra horizontal bar across its upper loop from die metal displacement. Struck-through and die chip errors carry premiums proportional to the dramatic visual impact of the error and whether it falls in a prominent location such as Washington's portrait.
The 1958 proof quarter was struck at Philadelphia expressly for collectors, with 875,652 pieces produced. Unlike business strikes, proof coins are made with specially prepared, highly polished dies and carefully selected planchets. The resulting coins have mirror-like fields and — when the die frosting is sufficiently heavy — frosted cameo portrait devices that contrast dramatically against the brilliant reflective background.
The "Deep Cameo" or DCAM designation requires the strongest possible contrast: portrait devices must be heavily frosted white, and the fields must be virtually black-mirror reflective. This contrast is a result of the proof die's surface treatment, which frosted the design elements while leaving the field smooth. Early strikes from fresh proof dies produce the deepest cameo; as the die wears, the frosting diminishes and later coins receive only Cameo (CAM) or standard designations.
PCGS and NGC both award the DCAM designation to qualifying 1958 proofs, and it dramatically affects value. A standard 1958 proof in PR-65 might sell for $30–$50, while a PR-68 DCAM has sold for $8,519 at Heritage Auctions (April 2017, PCGS data). Only a small fraction of the 875,652 proofs struck that year survived in true Deep Cameo condition; PCGS population data shows the vast majority of surviving proofs are standard or cameo designated, making DCAM pieces genuinely scarce.
Found one of these errors on your coin? Get an instant value estimate using the calculator above.
Calculate My Value →
| Variety | Mint | Mintage | Est. Surviving | Survival Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1958-P (No Mint Mark) | Philadelphia | 6,360,000 | ~636,000 | ~10% |
| 1958-D (Denver) | Denver | 78,124,900 | ~7,812,000 | ~10% |
| 1958 Proof | Philadelphia | 875,652 | ~350,000 | ~40% |
| Total | P & D | ~85,360,552 | — | — |
Metal: 90% Silver, 10% Copper | Weight: 6.30 grams | Diameter: 24.30 mm | Edge: Reeded
Designer: John Flanagan | Series: Washington Quarters (1932–1964) | Silver content: 0.18084 troy oz per coin
The 1958 Philadelphia issue represents an 86% decline from the 1957 Philadelphia output of 46,532,000 coins — making it the second-lowest mintage Philadelphia Washington quarter of the silver era (1932–1964) and the 16th lowest in the entire series. Despite this, roll-hoarding in the early 1960s means Gem examples are plentiful today. The Denver issue, despite its much larger mintage, is roughly twice as rare in true Gem condition because far fewer rolls were saved.
Washington's cheek and hair detail above the ear are flat and smooth. The eagle's breast feathers are heavily merged or absent. Lettering and rim are still mostly intact. Value is essentially the silver melt floor: approximately $13–$19 depending on spot price. No numismatic premium is added over melt in this grade range.
Hair strands above Washington's ear begin separating in VF; individual curls become more distinct toward EF-40. The eagle's leg feathers and breast show wear but retain some relief. No original luster remains. Value hovers just above melt at $17–$20 for most examples. Attractive EF coins can approach $22–$25.
No wear on the highest design points — check Washington's cheek, hair over the ear, and the eagle's breast. Original cartwheel luster is present, flowing across the fields. Contact marks and bag marks are common at MS-60 to MS-63. MS-65 gems must show sharp, clean fields and Washington's face free of distracting marks. Values range from $20 to $34 for this tier.
Superb gems with full luster, minimal contact marks, and sharp strike. At MS-66, examples are relatively common for the Philadelphia issue and sell for $30–$50. MS-67 requires nearly perfect surfaces — most known examples are mint-set or album-toned. MS-68 examples are extraordinarily rare. Top-grade coins in this tier can reach hundreds to thousands of dollars.
📱 CoinKnow makes it easy to match your coin's condition against graded reference examples — simply photograph your coin and compare it to the certified population for the 1958 quarter — a coin identifier and value app.
The right venue depends on your coin's grade, whether it's certified, and how quickly you want to sell. Higher-grade and error coins always benefit from professional grading first.
The premier venue for certified high-grade and variety coins. Heritage has set multiple auction records for the 1958 quarter, including the $4,800 Type B Reverse and $4,560 MS68 sale. Best for coins graded MS-66 and above, certified Type B Reverse examples, DCAM proofs, and documented error coins. Expect 15–20% buyer's premium.
The largest market for mid-grade silver Washington quarters. Review recently completed 1958 Washington quarter sold listings and realized prices to price your coin competitively. Circulated coins and certified MS-64 to MS-66 examples move reliably on eBay; raw (ungraded) gems are harder to price appropriately without PCGS/NGC certification.
Convenient for quick same-day sales of circulated silver quarters in any quantity. Dealers typically offer 80–90% of melt for worn coins and a fair premium for Gem and variety examples if they know what they're looking at. Bring any research you've done — knowing your coin's grade and variety saves negotiation time.
The r/Coins4Sale and r/CoinSales communities are active peer-to-peer markets. Excellent for mid-range certified coins ($15–$150), where eBay fees would eat into margins. Requires establishing Reddit account history and posting clear photos. Buyers are knowledgeable — transparency about condition and any issues is expected.
Use our free calculator — plug in your mint mark, condition, and any errors for an instant estimate based on real auction data.
Calculate My 1958 Quarter Value →